Heat Pump vs Furnace Operating Cost by Climate Zone

Heat pump versus furnace is usually framed as an efficiency contest, and on raw efficiency the heat pump wins by a wide margin — a coefficient of performance of 2.5 to 4.0 against a gas furnace’s 0.95. But efficiency is not the same as operating cost, because the two systems buy different fuels at different prices, and the price of those fuels varies enormously by region. In some climate zones the heat pump wins by a factor of two. In others, the furnace is cheaper to run.

The deciding variables are three: your local electricity price per kWh, your local gas price per therm, and your climate zone’s heating load. The fuel economy calculator handles the energy-per-unit conversions; here is how the comparison plays out zone by zone.

The conversion that makes comparison possible

Electricity and natural gas are sold in different units, so all cost comparisons have to land on a common measure: cost per million BTU of delivered heat.

System Efficiency Fuel unit BTU per unit
Gas furnace (condensing) 95% AFUE Therm 100,000 BTU
Gas furnace (standard) 80% AFUE Therm 100,000 BTU
Heat pump (cold climate) COP 2.5 at 17°F kWh 3,412 BTU
Heat pump (standard) COP 3.2 at 47°F kWh 3,412 BTU
Electric resistance COP 1.0 kWh 3,412 BTU

A condensing furnace delivers 95,000 BTU of heat per therm. A cold-climate heat pump at COP 2.5 delivers 8,530 BTU per kWh. From there, it’s just multiplication by local prices.

Zone-by-zone cost picture

Using representative 2026 prices — national averages around $0.17/kWh for electricity and $1.30/therm for gas, with regional variation — the cost per million BTU of delivered heat works out as follows.

Region Elec $/kWh Gas $/therm Heat pump $/MMBtu Furnace $/MMBtu Cheaper
New England 0.28 1.75 $32.80 $18.40 Furnace
Mid-Atlantic 0.17 1.40 $19.90 $14.70 Furnace (narrow)
Pacific Northwest 0.11 1.50 $12.90 $15.80 Heat pump
Southeast 0.14 1.45 $16.40 $15.30 Near parity
Mountain West 0.12 1.10 $14.10 $11.60 Furnace
California (PG&E) 0.33 1.90 $38.70 $20.00 Furnace

The pattern is clear and counterintuitive: high-electricity coastal markets favor gas furnaces on operating cost, despite the heat pump’s efficiency advantage. Cheap-hydro electricity in the Northwest flips the result entirely.

Why cold-climate performance changes the math

The table above uses a COP of 2.5, which is roughly what a cold-climate heat pump achieves at 17°F. Below that temperature, capacity and efficiency both fall. At 5°F, a standard heat pump’s COP can drop to 1.5, at which point it is barely better than electric resistance heat.

This matters because heating load isn’t uniform across a winter — it’s concentrated in the coldest hours. A heat pump sized for average conditions may run at poor efficiency during exactly the period that determines the winter’s cost. Cold-climate models rated for full capacity at 5°F solve this, but they cost 20–30% more than standard units.

Worked example: two homes, same heating load

Home A — Boston, 55 million BTU annual heating load. Electricity at $0.28/kWh, gas at $1.75/therm. Heat pump at COP 2.5 costs $32.80 per MMBtu, or about $1,804 per year. Furnace at 95% AFUE costs $18.40 per MMBtu, or about $1,012 per year. The furnace is $792/year cheaper to run.

Home B — Seattle, same 55 million BTU load. Electricity at $0.11/kWh, gas at $1.50/therm. Heat pump costs $12.90 per MMBtu, about $710/year. Furnace costs $15.80 per MMBtu, about $869/year. The heat pump is $159/year cheaper.

Over a 15-year equipment life, Home A’s furnace saves about $11,900 in operating cost. Home B’s heat pump saves about $2,400. Those numbers are small relative to installation cost differences, which is why equipment price, rebates, and cooling-season benefits usually dominate the decision.

Frequently asked questions

Does the heat pump also cool the house? Yes, and that’s often the decisive factor. A heat pump replaces both the furnace and the air conditioner, so the comparison should be against furnace-plus-AC, not furnace alone. In cooling-heavy climates the combined savings often outweigh the heating-cost penalty.

At what electricity price does a heat pump become cheaper than gas? Roughly $0.15/kWh against $1.30/therm gas. Above that, gas generally wins on operating cost at a COP of 2.5.

Do heat pumps work in very cold climates? Cold-climate models operate down to −13°F with reduced capacity, and typically retain 70–80% of rated capacity at 5°F. Standard models need a backup heat source below about 20°F.

Are there rebates that change the calculation? Frequently yes — the federal 25C credit covers 30% of heat pump installation up to $2,000, and many states add their own. Rebates change the upfront cost, not the operating cost.

Do the arithmetic for your own rates

National averages hide a spread wide enough to reverse the answer. The two numbers that decide it for your house are your delivered electricity price and your delivered gas price — both visible on a recent utility bill. Everything else follows from those two figures and the heating load.

Convert your own consumption into comparable units before deciding, and factor in the cooling-season benefit if you’re comparing against a furnace-plus-AC combination rather than a furnace alone.

Leave a Reply